Advice / Insurance
Can you choose your own contractor on an insurance claim?
Your insurer has sent its own contractor, but you'd rather use someone you trust. Here's how it usually works, and the catch to watch for.

The short version
- Many policies let the insurer choose between their contractor and a cash settlement.
- If you choose your own contractor, the insurer may only pay their own contractor's rates.
- Agree it in writing before any work starts.
- If the insurer's delays forced you into using your own contractor, that may change what's fair.
It's a common frustration: something has gone badly wrong at home, and the insurer sends a company you've never heard of. You might already know a firm you trust, or want someone local who can start sooner. Whether you can use them depends on your policy, and on how you agree it.
How most UK policies work
Many home policies say the insurer decides how to settle a claim. Usually that means one of three things:
- They arrange the repairs using their own contractor.
- They pay a cash settlement so you can arrange the work yourself.
- They pay your chosen contractor directly, if they agree to it.
The catch is the cash settlement. Insurers often get lower rates from their own suppliers, so if you choose your own contractor they may only pay what the work would have cost them, leaving you to cover the difference.
How to agree it properly
- Ask earlyTell the insurer or loss adjuster you'd like to use your own contractor before any work starts.
- Get a detailed quoteA clear schedule of works and costs makes it easier for the insurer to approve.
- Get it in writingConfirm what they'll pay, whether they'll pay the contractor directly, and what happens if extra damage is found.
- Check the guaranteeRepairs by the insurer's contractor are usually guaranteed by the insurer. With your own, the guarantee is your contractor's.
Using a restoration specialist alongside the insurer
For water and fire damage, the drying and cleaning stage matters as much as the rebuild. A specialist who records moisture readings, photos and progress gives the insurer what it needs to approve the next stage, which often means fewer delays whoever does the final decorating.
Common questions
Do I have to use my insurer's contractor?
Not always, but your insurer may only pay what their contractor would have charged. Check your policy and agree it first.
Will the insurer pay my contractor directly?
Some will, once they've approved the quote. Others pay you a cash settlement. Ask before work starts.
What if I'm unhappy with the insurer's contractor?
Raise it with the insurer in writing. If it isn't resolved, use their complaints process.
Can I use a loss assessor?
Yes. A loss assessor works for you rather than the insurer and usually charges a percentage of the claim.



